Shallows by Tim Winton & Goodbye Goldilocks by Judith Arthy

Reviewed by
February–March 1985, no. 68
Nancy Keesing reviews 'Shallows' by Tim Winton and 'Goodbye Goldilocks' by Judith Arthy

Shallows

by Tim Winton

Allen & Unwin, 235 pp, $14.95, 0 86861 793 8

Book Cover 2 Small

Goodbye Goldilocks

by Judith Arthy

Angus & Robertson, 149 p, $12.95, 0 207 14899 6

Shallows by Tim Winton & Goodbye Goldilocks by Judith Arthy

Reviewed by
February–March 1985, no. 68

Those who read the gloomy criticisms of modern education by some educationalists might be pardoned for wondering whether any but the most privileged children nowadays can hope to gain mastery of their language or development of their mind and talent. Meanwhile, the talented young blithely make nonsense of crabbed and intolerant age. Paul Zanetti, aged twenty-three, wins the Walkely Award for a political cartoon. Paul Radley, while still in his teens, and Tim Winton, barely older, won Australian Vogel Awards and continue writing with force and imagination.

Winton is now twenty-four. Shallows is his second good novel. It is set in a fictional West Australian whaling town called Angelus. Although I have never been to Albany (where Winton had part of his education), I suspect I might find it recognisable after reading Winton’s devoted and detailed account of Angelus. The time of the action is now, or a year or so ago, but the story ranges through much history. Change is inevitable for whaling ports and industries but whether it should come abruptly or gradually is still debatable.


Subscribe to ABR


Nancy Keesing reviews 'Shallows' by Tim Winton and 'Goodbye Goldilocks' by Judith Arthy

Shallows

by Tim Winton

Allen & Unwin, 235 pp, $14.95, 0 86861 793 8

Book Cover 2 Small

Goodbye Goldilocks

by Judith Arthy

Angus & Robertson, 149 p, $12.95, 0 207 14899 6

You May Also Like

From the New Issue

Leave a comment

If you are an ABR subscriber, you will need to sign in to post a comment.

If you have forgotten your sign in details, or if you receive an error message when trying to submit your comment, please email your comment (and the name of the article to which it relates) to ABR Comments. We will review your comment and, subject to approval, we will post it under your name.

Please note that all comments must be approved by ABR and comply with our Terms & Conditions.