Stop Being Reasonable by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

Reviewed by
June–July 2019, no. 412
Alex Tighe reviews 'Stop Being Reasonable' by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

Stop Being Reasonable

by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

NewSouth, $27.99 pb, 204 pp, 9781742235875

Stop Being Reasonable by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

Reviewed by
June–July 2019, no. 412

If you’ve somehow avoided listening to podcasts, you will have missed out on the recent explosion of long-form audio storytelling – and I mean it, you’ve really missed out. The show which pioneered the form, This American Life (TAL), pulls a cool four to five million listeners each week, and you don’t get those numbers for nothing. TAL takes ordinary people, tells their stories, and then – this is their secret sauce – makes a whimsical pivot to the larger idea the story gives us about the world. It’s a simple formula that’s had a subtle but widespread ripple effect on journalism. Narrative is being used to explain, to explore, to interrogate – as an invitation to thought.

I’ll return to the notion of storytelling as an invitation to thought. Before that, there’s a more specific reason why I mention TAL here. If you were around Kings Cross in late 2016, you would have seen Eleanor Gordon-Smith, microphone in hand, walking along Darlinghurst Road and recording for the program. The idea for her piece was: woman on street, woman gets catcalled, woman confronts catcallers, convinces them to stop. It’s a great pitch, made more compelling by the fact that Gordon-Smith was (and I assume still is) a weapons-grade arguer – she was a philosophy tutor at the University of Sydney at the time and had previously been a world-class debater. Convincing the men would be easy, no?

Alex Tighe reviews 'Stop Being Reasonable' by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

Stop Being Reasonable

by Eleanor Gordon-Smith

NewSouth, $27.99 pb, 204 pp, 9781742235875

You May Also Like

From the New Issue

Leave a comment

If you are an ABR subscriber, you will need to sign in to post a comment.

If you have forgotten your sign in details, or if you receive an error message when trying to submit your comment, please email your comment (and the name of the article to which it relates) to ABR Comments. We will review your comment and, subject to approval, we will post it under your name.

Please note that all comments must be approved by ABR and comply with our Terms & Conditions.