The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth by John Hirst

Reviewed by
February–March 2001, no. 228
Geoffrey Bolton reviews 'The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth' by John Hirst

The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth

by John Hirst

Oxford University Press, $34.95 hb, 388 pp, 0195506200

The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth by John Hirst

Reviewed by
February–March 2001, no. 228

When John Hirst accepted the challenge of writing a history of Federation of scholarly quality but fit for a broad popular readership, he may have felt himself on a hiding to nothing. Previous historians have succeeded in convincing Australians that the story of the making of the Australian Commonwealth is at best dull. Who wants to know about a collection of hirsute, largely overweight, and overdressed middle-class politicians arguing about the nexus between the Senate and the House of Representatives?

Unlike the Americans, we did not begin with a ringing declaration of independence from Mother England. Unlike the French Revolution, we offer no images of impassioned crowds storming Pentridge. ‘Advance Australia Fair’ is no substitute for the Marseillaise. Unlike the old Soviet Union, our constitution contains no mission statement of community values and aspirations, and some, such as Don Watson, argue that we are the poorer for it.

Even during the Federation referenda of the late 1890s, Labor writers in Victoria and New South Wales were damning the proposed federal constitution as a bourgeois plot enabling capitalist bosses to organise more efficiently. The federal parliament, claimed the Brisbane Worker, would deliver neither one-man­one-vote, women’s suffrage, nor a White Australia policy. The new Commonwealth achieved the lot within eighteen months of its creation.

Geoffrey Bolton reviews 'The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth' by John Hirst

The Sentimental Nation: The making of the Australian Commonwealth

by John Hirst

Oxford University Press, $34.95 hb, 388 pp, 0195506200

You May Also Like

From the New Issue

Leave a comment

If you are an ABR subscriber, you will need to sign in to post a comment.

If you have forgotten your sign in details, or if you receive an error message when trying to submit your comment, please email your comment (and the name of the article to which it relates) to ABR Comments. We will review your comment and, subject to approval, we will post it under your name.

Please note that all comments must be approved by ABR and comply with our Terms & Conditions.