Surrender Australia?: Essays in the study and uses of Australian history edited by Andrew Markus and M.C. Ricklefs

by
May 1985, no. 70

Surrender Australia?: Essays in the study and uses of Australian history edited by Andrew Markus and M.C. Ricklefs

Allen & Unwin, $8.95, 149 pp

Surrender Australia?: Essays in the study and uses of Australian history edited by Andrew Markus and M.C. Ricklefs

by
May 1985, no. 70

At the August 1984 conference of Australian historians, the Public Lecture Theatre at Melbourne University was packed to hear a panel of distinguished colleagues discuss Geoffrey Blainey’s creation of the public debate on Asian immigration. Blainey did not attend. His mentor Manning Clark did, though he refused to denounce his most famous pupil. Surrender Australia? is largely the product of that meeting. Historians take themselves rather seriously and already there have been complaints that a concerted attack on one of the discipline’s favourite sons is unprecedented. Letters to The Age were denouncing the book as ‘an attack on a great Australian’ well before it was published or the correspondents could see the contents. Public controversy is certainly rare among local historians, being largely confined to such esoteric matters as whether Australia was settled to get rid of convicts or to acquire flax, an argument in which Blainey took a major role. In a small society, academics do not usually denounce each other in the fashion long acceptable in central Europe or America. Equally, they do not often engage in public controversy on matters which draw in the vulgar multitude. While professional historians are not very radical, they mostly subscribe to liberal views, among which tolerance for minorities and for the ideas of others are the most acceptable. Blainey presented his colleagues with a dilemma. They could draw up their skirts and pass by on the other side, or they could publicly disagree with him.

James Jupp reviews 'Surrender Australia? Essays in the study and uses of Australian history' edited by Andrew Markus and M.C. Ricklefs

Surrender Australia?: Essays in the study and uses of Australian history

edited by Andrew Markus and M.C. Ricklefs

Allen & Unwin, $8.95, 149 pp

You May Also Like

Leave a comment

If you are an ABR subscriber, you will need to sign in to post a comment.

If you have forgotten your sign in details, or if you receive an error message when trying to submit your comment, please email your comment (and the name of the article to which it relates) to ABR Comments. We will review your comment and, subject to approval, we will post it under your name.

Please note that all comments must be approved by ABR and comply with our Terms & Conditions.