Ian McNeill
Greg Lockhart reviews 'Fighting to the Finish: The Australian Army and the Vietnam War 1968–1975' by Ashley Ekins, with Ian McNeill
Fighting to the Finish does not get off to a good start; its title is overstated. The First Australian Task Force (1ATF), trimmed down in 1970 from three to two battalions, withdrew from the Vietnam War by December 1971. The small remaining advisory group withdrew in December 1972. Fighting finished in April 1975, when more than 180 battalions of the People’s Army of Vietnam (PAVN) swarmed around Saigon, causing it to fall. It hardly seems sensible to declare that the Australian Army fought to the finish over two years before the end of the war.
... (read more)Jeffrey Grey reviews ‘Australia’s Battlefields in Viet Nam: A traveller’s guide’ by Gary McKay and ‘On the Offensive: The Australian Army in the Vietnam War 1967–1968’ by Ian McNeill and Ashley Ekins
For most Australians, certainly for those under the age of forty, ‘Vietnam’ is either an item on school curricula or a slightly off-the-beaten-path tourist destination. History or holiday. This may affront some, especially the small groups on either side of the 1960s cultural and political divide that cannot let go, but it is a sign of a generational shift and of the creation of the distance between ourselves and the event that is necessary for enhanced understanding and reconciliation between Australians and the Vietnamese.
... (read more)