Simon Coghlan reviews 'Run, Spot, Run: The ethics of keeping pets' by Jessica Pierce

Simon Coghlan reviews 'Run, Spot, Run: The ethics of keeping pets' by Jessica Pierce

Run, Spot, Run: The ethics of keeping pets

by Jessica Pierce

University of Chicago Press (Footprint) $52.95 hb, 256 pp, 9780226209890

A sea change has occurred in the way we regard pets. In recent decades the West has fervently embraced pet keeping. Australia has one of the world's highest levels of pet ownership. Moreover, pets are described as 'members of the family'. Pets sleep on our beds, join us on holidays, and receive human-grade medical treatment. Furthermore, our moral concern for animals has generally risen. Witness the public concern with Australian live animal export and the greyhound racing industry.

American bioethicist Jessica Pierce explores some consequences of this social shift in Run, Spot, Run: The ethics of keeping pets. The title, borrowed from the blandly happy 1930s Dick and Jane school readers, is double-edged. Spot the frolicking dog is, like Dick and Jane, having fun. But Spot is also running from us. Pet keeping is a story of brutality as well as love. Pierce both celebrates pet–human relations and reveals their darker side. As the book proceeds, the darkness gathers.

Run, Spot, Run unflinchingly exposes what has made contemporary pet–person relations troubling and hence 'ethically rich'. Of course, some unsettling elements were never really hidden. The 'single biggest moral problem', the author rightly says, is the many 'relinquished animals languishing in ... shelters, pounds, and humane societies'.

Read the rest of this article by purchasing a subscription to ABR Online, or subscribe to the print edition to receive access to ABR Online free of charge.

If you are a single issue subscriber you will need to upgrade your subscription to view back issues.

If you are already subscribed, click here to log in.

Published in October 2016, no. 385
Simon Coghlan

Simon Coghlan

Simon Coghlan is a philosopher at the Australian Catholic University. He is also a veterinarian at a companion animal vet clinic in Melbourne. He writes on moral philosophy, animal ethics, professional ethics, and environmental philosophy.