Neal Blewett reviews Bob Carr

Acuity and self-indulgence from an ex-foreign minister

‘Dear Dr Blewett, I am writing to you ... concerning your intention to publish the diary you kept during the first Keating Government ... Whether any legal action, criminal or civil, is initiated would be entirely a matter for the Commonwealth government and relevant authorities ... Against the background of the expectations of confidentiality with which you are familiar during your time as a minister ... I am unable to lend my support to your proposal to publish diaries recording the confidential deliberations of the Cabinet of which you were a member.’

So wrote Max Moore-Wilton (Secretary, the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet) on 9 June 1998, prior to the publication of this writer’s A Cabinet Diary (1999). Yet some seven years had elapsed between the events recorded in the diary and its publication. The speed of contemporary history is such that the age of Paul Keating seemed, even at the time, to belong to another world. Moreover, I had excluded from A Cabinet Diary nearly all references to foreign affairs, particularly some colourful remarks on our Pacific neighbours by the foreign minister. Contrast this with Bob Carr’s Diary of a Foreign Minister, which is all about foreign affairs and which appears within twelve months of some of the events described. This gives the book a wonderful immediacy, but does it arouse the ire of powerful bureaucrats? Did Carr too receive a threatening epistle from on high?

Read the rest of this article by purchasing a subscription to ABR Online, or subscribe to the print edition to receive access to ABR Online free of charge.

If you are a single issue subscriber you will need to upgrade your subscription to view back issues.

If you are already subscribed, click here to log in.